JYIL JAPANESE YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW

All Issues

Volume 65 (2022)
CONTENTS

ARTICLES

CHALLENGES TO “THE LAW OF TREATIES” IN DIVERSIFYING TREATY RELATIONS

Koji Nishimoto
Introductory Note
1
Aurélie Tardieu
Lex Specialis Derogat Lei Generali and Diversification of Treaty Relations
6
Maria Xiouri
Challenges to Article 60 VCLT on the Termination or Suspension of the Operation of a Treaty in Response to Its Material Breach: The Relationship with Countermeasures
45
Keun-Gwan Lee
Reconceptualising the Law of State Succession in Respect of Treaties
—Checking the ILC’s “Codification” Efforts Against Subsequent State Practice—
79
Jure Zrilič
Armed Conflicts and the Law of Treaties: Recent Developments and Reappraisal of the Doctrine in Light of the Wars in Syria and Ukraine
107
OKANO Masataka
Changing Roles of Treaties in Foreign Policy
138

GLOBALIZATION OF SOCIETY AND INTERNATIONAL FAMILY LAW IN JAPAN

Takami Hayashi
Introductory Note
167
Ryoko Yamaguchi
Interests of the Child in Child Abduction and Visitation Cases
—Differences Between Japan’s Domestic and International Criteria—
169
Takami Hayashi
Transboundary Child Protection in Japan
191
HAYAKAWA Shinichiro
Japanese Perspective on Legal Issues of International Surrogacy
213
Moonsook Kim
International Adoption in Korea
231
Manabu Iwamoto
International Recovery of Maintenance in Japan
247

CHANGES AND EVOLUTION IN LEGAL DOCTRINES BASED UPON STATE SOVEREIGNTY

Jean-Marc Thouvenin
On Different Res: Res Judicata, Res Interpretata, Res Praescripta (or Indicata), Res Deliberata
270
Tomonori Mizushima
Lex Lata and Lex Ferenda of Sovereign Immunity
301

JAPANESE DIGEST OF INTERNATIONAL LAW

Atsuko Kanehara
The Impact on Japan’s Coast Guard and Maritime Security Caused by China’s Coast Guard Law of 2021
320

CASES AND ISSUES IN JAPANESE PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW

Chisato Nakamura
Failure of Service of Judgment Documents and Public Policy Control at The Stage of Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments
336
Miho Shin
Habitual Residence in Japanese Private International Law
348

BOOK REVIEWS

Taku Kumagai
Kokusaiterorizumu nitaisuru Hotekikisei no Kozo: Terorizumu Boshi Shojoyaku niokeru Saibankankatsuken no Kentou [The Structure of Legal Control of International Terrorism: An Analysis of Anti-Terrorism Conventions], by Takayo Ando. Tokyo: Kokusaishoin, 2020. Pp. 414.
362
Ren Yatsunami
Seisaku-jitsugen-katei no Gurobaruka [The Globalized Policy Cycle], edited by Yuki Asano, Hiroki Harada, Takeshi Fujitani, and Dai Yokomizo. Tokyo: Koubundo, 2019. Pp. xi, 385.
250
Masami Maruyama
Economic Sanctions in International Law and Practice, edited by Masahiko Asada. London and New York: Routledge, 2020. Pp. xiv, 256.
365
MORIKAWA Koichi and FUJISAWA Iwao
Gendai Kokusaiho no Choryu: Sakamoto Shigeki, Yakushiji Kimio Ryosensei Koki Kinen Ronbunshu [Tides in Contemporary International Law: Essays on the Occasion of the 70th Birthdays of SAKAMOTO Shigeki and YAKUSHIJI Kimio], Two Volumes, edited by ASADA Masahiko, KIRIYAMA Takanobu, TOKUGAWA Shinji, NISHIMURA Tomoaki, and HIGUCHI Kazuhiko. Tokyo: Toshindo, 2020. Pp. xxi, 509, xx, 511.
371
Megumi Ochi
Reparation for Victims of Armed Conflict, by Cristián Correa, Shuichi Furuya,and Clara Sandoval. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2021. Pp. viii, 293.
378
Taira Nishi
Kokusaiho no Tanjo: Yoroppa Kokusaiho karano Tenkan [The Birth of International Law: Transformation from European International Law], by Aiko Nakai. Kyoto: Kyoto University Press, 2020. Pp. xvi, 607.
381
Yukiko Oda
Hagu Joyaku no Riron to Jitsumu: Kokkyo wo Koeta Ko no Ubaiai Funso no Kaiketsu no Tameni [Theory and Practice of the Hague Child Abduction Convention: For the Rapid and Better Resolution of Cross-Border Custody Disputes], edited by Mikiko Otani and Yuko Nishitani. Kyoto: Horitsu Bunka Sha, 2021. Pp. 338.
385
Yota Negishi
Beisyu Jinken Seido no Kenkyu: Beisyu Jinken Iinkai to Beisyu Jinken Saibansyo no Chosen to Sono Eikyo [Study on Inter-American Human Rights System: Challenges and Impacts of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights], by Yoshitaka Saito. Tokyo: Hokuju Syuppan, 2021. Pp. xii, 462.
390
Dai Tamada
Changing Actors in International Law, edited by Karen N. Scott, Kathleen Claussen, Charles-Emmanuel Côté, and Atsuko Kanehara. Leiden: Brill/Nijhoff, 2020. Pp. xxviii, 415.
393
Satoshi Kodera
Kokusaiho no Genzai: Henten suru Gendai Sekai de Ho no Kanousei wo Toi naosu [International Law at Present: The Possibility of Law in the Everchanging World] edited by Koji Teraya and Kazuyori Ito. Tokyo: Nippon Hyoron Sha, 2020. Pp. xix, 423.
398
Hiromi Sato
Kokusaikeiho niokeru Jokansekinin to Sono Kokunaihoka [Command Responsibility in International Criminal Law and Its Implementation in National Criminal Law] by Kazuya Yokohama. Tokyo: Keio University Press, 2021. Pp. xii, 380.
402

JUDICIAL DECISIONS IN JAPAN

I. Public International Law

Osaka High Court, Judgment, September 11, 2018
407
Supreme Court (2nd Petty Bench), Judgment, February 1, 2021
Admissibility of Evidence Obtained by Transborder Remote Access — Article 32 of the Convention on Cybercrime — Possible Infringement of the Sovereignty of the State Where the Server Is Located
414
Nagoya High Court, Judgment, January 13, 20
Deportation of a Foreign National Prior to the Institution of Litigation Against the Decision of Non-Recognition of Refugee Status — Possible Illegality Under the State Redress Act — Article 14(1) of the ICCPR — Non-Refoulement Principle – The Right of Access to the Court
416

II. Private Interantional Law

Supreme Court (3rd Petty Bench), Judgment, May 25, 2021
Enforcement of Foreign Judgment — Punitive Damages — Contrary to Public Policy
423
Intellectual Property High Court, Judgment, September 29, 2021
Applicable Law — Copyright — Employee Work — Copyright Transfer
426
Tokyo District Court, Judgment, February 12, 2020
Lawsuit for State Redress — Conduct of a Public Employee Outside of Japan
430
Tokyo District Court, Judgment, November 20, 2020
Applicable Law — Characterization — Succession to Immovables Abroad — Unjust Enrichment
433
Tokyo District Court, Judgment, January 21, 2021
Nationality Law — Case Requesting Confirmation of Japanese Nationality — Loss of Japanese Nationality due to the Acquisition of Foreign Nationality
438
Tokyo District Court, Judgment, March 9, 2021
Enforcement of Foreign Judgment — Service of Documents During the Litigation Proceedings — Contrary to Procedural Public Policy
443

CHRONOLOGY OF JAPANESE FOREIGN AFFAIRS IN 2021

448

CHRONOLOGICAL LIST OF TREATIES AND OTHER INTERNATIONAL AGREEMENTS CONCLUDED BY JAPAN IN 2021

459
* Selected Treaties Concluded and Signed by Japan are available on-line (click here).

DOCUMENTS

ACTIVITIES

I. Activities of the International Law Association of Japan
462
II. Activities of Related Academic Associations in Japan
468

INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBMISSIONS TO THE JAPANESE YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW

483