JYIL JAPANESE YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW

All Issues

Volume 51 (2008)
CONTENTS

On Launching the Japanese Yearbook of International Law

Shigeru Oda,
President, International Law Association of Japan
1

Article

Hisashi Owada
Reconcepualization of the International Rule of Law in a Globalizing World
3

THE LAW OF THE SEA: ENDURING PRINCIPLES AND CONTEMPORARY CHALLENGES

Atsuko Kanehara
Challenging the Fundamental Principle of the Freedom of the High Seas and the Flag State Principle Expressed by Recent Non-flag State Measures on the High Seas
21
Moritaka Hayashi
International Measures to Combat Illegal, Unreported and Unregulated (IUU) Fishing and Japan
57
Akio Morita
Piracy Jure Gentium Revisited
— For Japan’s Future Contribution —
76
Shigeki Sakamoto
Japan-China Dispute Over Maritime Boundary Delimitation
— From a Japanese Perspective —
98
Haiwen Zhang
Legal Issues Concerning the East China Sea Delimitation
— A Chinese Perspective on the Sino-Japanese the East China Sea Dispute —
119
Rüdiger Wolfrum
The Settlement of Disputes Before the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea
— A Progressive Development of International Law or Relying on Traditional Mechanisms? —
140
Naoya Okuwaki
The Basic Act on Ocean Policy and Japan’s Agendas for Legislative Improvement
164

DIVERGENCE AND UNIFICATION OF CHOICE OF LAW RULES FROM A GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE

Toshiyuki Kono
Comparative Analysis of Recent Developments in Private International Law in Japan and Europe from a Japanese Perspective
217
Peter Mankowski
Comparative Analysis of Recent Developments in Private International Law in Japan and Europe from a Japanese Perspective
241
Ronald A. Brand and Tabitha Fish
An American Perspective on the New Japanese Act on General Rules for Application of Laws
298
HUANG Renting
A Comparative Law Analysis on Some Recent Developments in the Conflict of Law Rules of Contract in Japan and China.
314
Moonsook Kim
On the Korean Private International Law
327
Yoshiaki Nomura
Harmonization and Diversification of Contract Conflicts
341

ACCESSION OF JAPAN TO THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT

Kyo Arai, Akira Mayama and Osamu Yoshida
Japan’s Accession to the ICC Statute and the ICC Cooperation Law
359
Kanako Takayama
Participation in the ICC and the National Criminal Law of Japan
384
Yasushi Masaki
Japan’s Entry to the International Criminal Court and the Legal Challenges It Faced
409

SPECIAL LECTURE

Shigeru Oda
International Court of Justice: Its Myth and Reality
427

JAPANESE DIGEST OF INTERNATIONAL LAW

Junichi Hosono and Junko Iwaishi
The 88th Hoshinmaru Case and the 53rd Tomimaru Case: Application to the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea by Japan for Prompt Release
438
Junji Nakagawa
Japan’s Retaliatory Action Against the United States’ Continued Dumping and Subsidy Offset Act of 2000 (Byrd Amendment).
454
SHIN Hae-Bong
Recent Legislative and Administrative Measures Against Human Trafficking in Japan
471

CASES AND ISSUES IN JAPANESE PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW

Dai Yokomizo
State Immunity from Civil Jurisdiction
485

BOOK REVIEWS

Kazuhiro Nakatani
21 Seiki Kokusaiho no Kadai — Ando Nisuke Sensei Koki Kinen [Agenda for International Law in the 21st Century: Festschrift in Honour of Professor Nisuke Ando’s 70th Birthday], edited by Masahiko Asada. Tokyo: Yushindo Kobun Sha, 2006.
496
Yoshihisa Hayakawa
America Kokusaishiho no Kiso Riron [Basic Theory on American Private International Law], by Hiroshi Matsuoka. Osaka: Osaka University Press, 2007.
500
Tadashi Mori
Jieiken no Gendaiteki Tenkai [The Right of Self-Defence in the Contemporary Context], edited by Shinya Murase. Tokyo: Toshindo, 2007.
503
Joel P. Trachtman
Anti-Dumping Laws and Practices of the New Users, edited by Junji Nakagawa. London: Cameron May, 2007.
506
Sookyeon Huh
Resolving the Russo-Japanese Territorial Dispute: Hokkaido-Sakhalin Relations (The Nissan Institute/Routledge Japanese studies series), by Brad Williams. London: Routledge, 2007.
508
Hyuck-Soo Yoo
The WTO in the Twenty-first Century : Dispute Settlement, Negotiation, and Regionalism in Asia, edited by Yasuhei Taniguchi, Alan Yanovich, and Jan Bohanes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.
510

JUDICIAL DECISIONS IN JAPAN

I. Public International Law

Supreme Court, Judgment, March 27, 2007
Treaty of Peace between Japan and the Republic of China — Joint Communiqué between Japan and the People’s Republic of China — Recognition of Government — Succession of Government — Incomplete or Partial Succession — Transfer of Ownership and Capacity to Sue and to Be Sued after Switch of Government Recognition
512
Supreme Court, Judgment, April 27, 2007
Article 14(b) of the Treaty of Peace with Japan — Article 11 of the Treaty of Peace between Japan and the Republic of China — Paragraph 5 of the Joint Communiqué between Japan and the People’s Republic of China — The Right to Claim Compensation for Damages for People Brought to Japan Against Their Will and the Renunciation Clause in the Joint Communiqué
518
Tokyo District Court, Ruling, January 24, 2007
State Immunity from Civil or Administrative Jurisdiction — Restrictive Theory of Immunity — Distinction between Acts jure imperii and Acts jure gestionis — Consent by a Foreign State to be Subjected to Dispositions by an Administrative Agency of the Forum State
533
Tokyo District Court, Judgment, February 2, 2007
Article 1 A(2) of the Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (1951) — Definition of the Term “being persecuted”— Persecution by Non-State Actors
544

II. Private Interantional Law

Supreme Court, Judgment, March 23, 2007
Surrogate Pregnancy — Surrogate Mother — Effect of a Judgment of a Foreign Court — Recognition of a Foreign Court Judgment — Final Judgment of a Foreign Court — Public Policy Exception — Legal Status of Parent-Child Relationship
552
Tokyo High Court, Judgment, October 30, 2006
Chi ld Support and Al imony Payments Between Chinese Nat ionals — International Adjudicatory Jurisdiction — Applicable Law in Child Support Cases — Applicable Law Concerning Preliminary Questions of the Age of Majority — Effect of Chinese Divorce Judgments — Recognition of Foreign Judgment
556
Tokyo District Court, Interlocutory Judgment, March 20, 2007
International Jurisdiction — General and Special Forum — Fairness Between the Parties and Due and Prompt Administration of Justice — International Concurrent Litigation — lis pendens — Meaning of ‘court’ in Code of Civil Procedure Article 142 — Abuse of Rights, Good Faith
561
Osaka District Court, Judgment, March 29, 200
International Adjudicatory Jurisdiction — Foreign Patent Rights — Applicable Law of Settlement Agreement
567

CHRONOLOGY OF JAPANESE FOREIGN AFFAIRS IN 2007

570

CHRONOLOGICAL LIST OF TREATIES AND OTHER INTERNATIONAL AGREEMENTS CONCLUDED BY JAPAN IN 2007

586

DOCUMENTS

I. Treaties
591
II. National Legislation
731
III. Contemporary Practice and Opinion
739

ACTIVITIES

I. Activities of the International Law Association of Japan
741
II. Activities of Related Academic Associations in Japan
741

INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBMISSIONS TO THE JAPANESE YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW